Barley Mowat 

The Best (and Worst) Tasting Rooms in Vancouver

with 16 comments

A long time ago, I decided to start a blog to talk about beer in BC. My goal was to keep track of local breweries and imports, then provide recommendations and rants to the public and/or anyone who engaged me in conversation for longer than 30 seconds.

It became very evident that this task would either not be possible, or lead to a liver transplant by the age of 35. So, I focused. Instead of all good beer in BC, I decided to limit my watchful commentary to just beer brewed in BC.

Okay, fine, that was too hard. Lower Mainland? Crap. Metro Van? Shit. How about Vancouver? Phew.

And that’s where we stand. The brewery scene has exploded to the point that I need to keep my judgemental eyes focused North of the Fraser and West of Boundary. I should be happy that there are over 1,000 distinct craft beers brewed in BC but, alas, happy ain’t my thang. Instead I’m mostly bitter that I can’t actually try it all anymore.

So, let’s talk about breweries with a Vancouver physical address, and see if I can’t insult someone with the same Mayor as me. Enjoy it while you can, because next year I’ll be focusing on fermentoriums under the same MLA.

In two more years, I’ll be limited to breweries in my neighbour Dave’s garage. Your beer is SHIT, Dave!

Even with such a tight focus as this, I can’t help but think “Holy crap has this ever changed since I was at UBC.” There are currently TWENTY SIX breweries in Vancouver proper. Fully 20 of these have only opened in the past few years, and there are at last five more being built. What a time to be a beer drinker!

Before we get going, though, let’s narrow our focus even more. Yes, there are 26 Brewery Licenses on record with the LCLB who list Vancouver as their physical production location. However, some of these are breweries without tasting rooms, or are virtual breweries, and still others are Molson.

So I’ll take that list of 26, and remove not just the obvious, but also Brewpubs, since this article is on Tasting Rooms, not Brewpubs. When we’re done whittling away, we wind up with a much more manageable task: 16 breweries. Even some of these are not traditional brewery tasting rooms. Some have restaurant licenses (Big Rock and Red Truck) allowing broader alcohol and food service. Some have no official tasting room at all, just a blonde brewmaster giving you samples while repeatedly asking you if you’re the cops (Storm). Still, 16 is a fine number.

Next up is how am I evaluating them? I like to focus on the beer, but a tasting room is a whole package experience, not just the product in your glass. To reflect this, I will give each brewery 4 to 12 points. 1-3 points for each of:

Beer: This is not just how good the beer is, but also the variety available. A tasting room with only one excellent beer available is just not as great as one with 8 good ales. While beer is just one of four things being evaluated, it is the most important and will serve as the tie breaker.

Ambience: Is the tasting room an enjoyable place? Is it special in some way, or just yet another wood-heavy square room?

Food: Everything from the ubiquitous cheese sticks and pepperoni, through a good food truck program, up to a whole kitchen. Also, are there drinks options for the non-beer guzzler in your group?

Brewery Feel: Part of a brewery tasting room is feeling like you’re visiting a brewery. Is the brewery on display? Has Graham With snuck up behind you to say hi? Or could you be in just any pub?

When you loosen the blinders enough to talk about more than just beer, some interesting results happen. Enough prelude and suspense, though, already. Let’s DO THIS THING.

GIS for “Do this thang” presented without comment.


16th Place: Dogwood – 8284 Sherbrooke St – @DogwoodBrew
4 pts – Beer: 1 – Ambience: 1 – Food: 1 – Brewery Feel: 1

Location. Location. Location. It’s the three most important rules in real estate, and it’s three key misses for Dogwood Brewing. Their location at the very bottom of Knight Street makes their lease cheap but also makes going there a royal PITA. Throw in a fairly normal tasting room, limited beer selection of variable quality, non-existent food program, and really the only reason to stop by is if you already live in the area.

14th Place (tie): Bomber – 1488 Adanac St – @BomberBrewing
6 pts – Beer: 1 – Ambience: 2 – Food: 1 – Brewery Feel: 2

Bomber started off okay and has been getting… okay-er, I guess? Their ESB is decent, and usually one or two of the balance are not bad at all, but by and large this is the type of beer meant to be consumed 18-at-a-time, out of a cooler full of ice during a softball game, and not by folks seriously into good beer. The cosy, warm tasting room and viewing portal onto the brewery makes a visit worthwhile, though.

14th Place (tie): Off the Rail – 1351 Adanac St – @OffTheRailBeer
6 pts – Beer: 1 – Ambience: 2 – Food: 1 – Brewery Feel: 2

Despite being just down the street from the uninspired Bomber, Off the Rail still manages to be the worst brewery in the area. If you’re a glutton for punishment, there are usually one or or two okay beers hiding in the long IPA-heavy off-flavours clinic what passes for a draught lineup, so keep looking. Once you find that okay beer, though, a pleasant and sunny elevated outlook over the Adanac bike path awaits you.

12th Place (tie): Powell Street – 1357 Powell St – @PowellBeer
6 pts – Beer: 2 – Ambience: 1 – Food: 1 – Brewery Feel: 2

It took a bit to work out the kinks of their new giant location, but PSCB’s finally hitting their stride. The regular lineup is a well brewed, well reviewed list of hop-heavy styles. As well, you can usually count on something sour and/or special to sneak into the line-up. The great beer, though, is held back by a bog standard wood-heavy tasting room, complete with a few jars of pepperoni on the counter.

12th Place (tie): Doan’s – 1830 Powell St – @DoansCBC
6 pts – Beer: 2 – Ambience: 2 – Food: 1 – Brewery Feel: 1

Occupying the tiny space that gave birth to Powell Street, Doan’s has upgraded Powell’s old minuscule tasting room to be positively tiny. Still, the cramped quarters impart an intimate feel that pairs well with the well brewed Rye-heavy beers on tap, and the old arcade machine. Too bad all the interesting brewing-action is locked away behind closed doors.

11th Place: Parallel 49 – 1950 Triumph St – @Parallel49Beer
7 pts – Beer: 2 – Ambience: 1 – Food: 2 – Brewery Feel: 2

P49’s tasting room is arguably the oldest craft tasting room in the city, and the age is reflected in the style. It feels and looks like a bar, and not even a particularly good one at that. Belying that impression, though, is a broad and ever-changing array of quality-brewed beers, and sporadic appearances by a food truck to offset that thirst. The sole indication that you’re in an actual brewery is the brewery-cam, but regularly scheduled tours do provide an alternate way to see what’s going on in back.

10th Place: Callister – 1338 Franklin St – @CallisterBeer
7 pts – Beer: 3 – Ambience: 1 – Food: 1 – Brewery Feel: 2

Callister is technically four breweries in one. While it sounds a bit scattered, the result is that there is always a wide variety of beer available over a incredibly diverse set of styles. Everything from the low-ABV cask conditioned pub sippers of Real Cask through the hop bombs of Machine, and all stops in between. Unfortunately, the impressive delivery ends with the full-sized pint glass. The room is plain, and food/not-beer options are almost non-existent.

9th Place: Big Rock – 310 W 4th Ave – @BigRockUrbanYVR
8 pts – Beer: 1 – Ambience: 2 – Food: 3 – Brewery Feel: 2

With almost-macro money comes almost-fancy finishings. Big Rock cheated the system by opening an attached restaurant instead of a tasting lounge but somehow elected to not also open a patio. Decent food and beverage options are rounded out by live music, and a out-of-the-way view of their brewhouse. Shame about the beer, though.

8th Place: Storm – 310 Commercial Drive – @StormBrewingVan
8 pts – Beer: 2 – Ambience: 2 – Food: 1 – Brewery Feel: 3

Storm doesn’t technically have a tasting room, but that doesn’t mean you can’t taste their beer… in a room. Okay, that room is also filled with brewing equipment, and the floor is frequently wet, but it still is a room. Storm’s regular offerings are offset by a constant rotation of Brain Storms, which can vary wildly in quality but are never boring. Food? Sure hope you brought some. The brewery feel is pegged here as you are literally standing on the floor of an operational brewery. Please don’t touch that knob.

7th Place: Granville Island – 1441 Cartwright St – @GranvilleBeer
9 Pts – Beer: 1 – Ambience: 2 – Food: 3 – Brewery Feel: 3

If you like elbowing tourists out of the way to try five terrible beers, then this is the place for you! Their one-offs are occasionally okay, but for whatever reason GIB keeps those to one tap at a time. However, there is a full kitchen in the back, and the entirety of the 10hl brewery is available for your inspection through the glass walls.

6th Place: Strange Fellows – 1345 Clark Dr – @Strange_Fellows
9 Pts – Beer: 3 – Ambience: 2 – Food: 1 – Brewery Feel: 3

A strong standard lineup is offset by a few interesting seasonals on the tap-board, but the real highlight of Strange Fellows’ new and expansive tasting room is the giant pile of beer-filled barrels that loom over the long tables. The fact that local art adorns the walls of an attached gallery doesn’t hurt, but the lack of any serious food offerings or a regular food truck does.

5th Place: Postmark – 55 Dunlevy Ave – @PostmarkBrewing
10 Pts – Beer: 1 – Ambience: 3 – Food: 3 – Brewery Feel: 3

The amazing space, good food, and wide array of alternate beverages belies the boring beer on tap. Postmark was built to service an imaginary flavour niche between the macro-drinking public and craft beer aficionados, so that insipid ale in your hand is insipid on purpose. However, when you consider everything BUT the beer, it’s a pretty swell place to hang out. A full kitchen serving excellent food, dozens of local wines on tap and even the odd cider on tap make for a happy group of people.

4th Place: Red Truck – 295 E 1st Ave – @RedTruckBeer
10 Pts – Beer: 2 – Ambience: 3 – Food: 3 – Brewery Feel: 2

Like Big Rock, Red Truck is straight up cheating. They don’t have a tasting room, but rather went and got themselves a full blown food-primary license. That little piece of paper puts much higher requirements on the establishment but let’s them have a patio. A freaking PATIO. The beer is nothing special, but even the most jaded beer geek will find something to not complain too loudly about while enjoying the rays, or listening to the sounds of their summer concert series.

3rd Place: 33 Acres – 15 W 8th Ave – @33Acres
10 Pts – Beer: 3 – Ambience: 3 – Food: 3 – Brewery Feel: 1

A lot of people don’t realize this, but keeping things clean is Rule Number One of brewing. 33 Acres’ stark white tasting room is a testimony to that rule. An expansive, diverse list of very-competently brewed beers is offset by an espresso bar, selection of baked goods, and a full blown kitchen serving a rotating list of tasty treats. Unfortunately, the brewery that makes all the magic is hidden behind two doors with small windows.

2nd Place: Main Street – 261 E 7th Ave – @MainStreetBeer
11 Pts – Beer: 2 – Ambience: 3 – Food: 3 – Brewery Feel: 3

What to do with a 100 year-old garage? Why, you clearly need to build a brewery in it, of course! Main Street is that brewery. Soaring ceilings, in-door trees, wooden beams, and a direct view over the legal-minimum-height 4 foot wall onto the brewing floor give you a sense of being there. A full kitchen compliments the beer with an array of hunger-neutralizing (if not amazing) food options.

1st Place: Brassneck – 2148 Main St – @BrassneckBrew
11 Pts – Beer: 3 – Ambience: 3 – Food: 2 – Brewery Feel: 3

The idea behind Brassneck’s tasting room is to deliver an experience in the heart of a brewery. The wooden walls that frame the open bench seating only go 1/2 way to the ceiling, and are filled with tiny cracks to give you an impression of the activity just on the other side. As well, the position of the tasting room between the brewhouse and the cellar occasionally requires rubber boot wearing brewers to cart kegs directly through the room. The long, varied list of top-notch brews only makes things better, and regularly scheduled food carts provide something to mop up all that delicious alcohol in your stomach.

Written by chuck

June 10th, 2016 at 2:53 pm

Posted in Breweries

16 Responses to 'The Best (and Worst) Tasting Rooms in Vancouver'

Subscribe to comments with RSS or TrackBack to 'The Best (and Worst) Tasting Rooms in Vancouver'.

  1. Hey! Thanks for the review.
    As I am sure you are well aware the city of Vancouver has lots of lovely bylaws and such around licensing. We exhausted every avenue we could to get a patio however it was made very clear that we will not be allowed one.

    JM Pelland

    10 Jun 16 at 16:53

  2. I would also like to point out that you did not actually have a beer the one time you were in here. Just a coffee. Have your opinion but don’t lie. You have never sat in our tasting room or the restaurant. You came for a meeting upstairs in our boardroom and drank coffee. If you want to discuss further you know where to find me.

    JM Pelland

    10 Jun 16 at 16:59

  3. JM Pelland, you’re funny. I don’t know the host of this site personally, but I’m sure that as someone in the beer community he has tried your beers… even if he didn’t do it that one time he came into your establishment. Don’t make yourself sound childish here. He didn’t lie, he commented on your lackluster beer. He didn’t say he drank it from the tap.

    Chad Chadson

    10 Jun 16 at 18:55

  4. JM: you must be confusing me with someone else. I have sat on both your restaurant and tasting rooms sides several times, and sampled many of your brews.

    I have actually never been in your boardroom, nor had coffee at your establishment. If you’re referring to the recent BC Beer Writers brunch that you hosted, I was not even there.

    chuck

    10 Jun 16 at 19:00

  5. But hey, check beeradvocate.com if you want more evidence of how “meh” your beer is JM.

    Chad Chadson

    10 Jun 16 at 19:02

  6. Nice Write-up!

    I agree a bunch with what you have said. I think that the East Van Beer Food is fine but not really much more than a snack or that inspired.

    Keep reviewing for us all!!

    Ashley

    10 Jun 16 at 19:08

  7. Also Big Rock should be happy with 9th, because the 4 times I was there was not memorable at all and I would rather roll the dice on Off the Rail and Dogwood.

    Opinions are great; Everyone has them

    Ashley

    10 Jun 16 at 19:11

  8. Are you aware that the brewer at postmark is now one of the best in the city?

    Thom

    10 Jun 16 at 22:30

  9. I missed you, Chuck! You’re the only local blogger who ever pisses anyone off.

    Ben

    10 Jun 16 at 23:00

  10. @Thom – I didn’t say the beer was faulted, just insipid. In fact, it takes a good level of brewing talent to purposely brew faultless insipid beer. Since Dominic took over, there have been a few flickers of creativity out of 55 Dunlevy but so far nothing seems to have stuck.

    @Ben – Missed you too, man. Just be glad that Boundary saved you from this list 🙂 Maybe I’ll do a follow-up of “Breweries What Chuck Can Ride His New Ebike Too”…

    chuck

    10 Jun 16 at 23:16

  11. @Chuck I was thinking the same thing. We’d have been pretty low on this list by these criteria, particularly if you’re docking points for location

    Ben

    11 Jun 16 at 10:42

  12. You’d probably do better than you think. The location only factored in to highlight the other scores for Dogwood. You guys are worth the trip.

    Let’s see:
    Beer: 3, Ambience: 2, Food: 1, Brewery Feel: 3

    9 pts, tied with Strange Fellows for 6th. That ain’t bad, at all.

    Also, in a thread on reddit where I recommended your brewery, I wrote this: “Sure, the view of a Burnaby industrial strip mall parking lot is not the same as a patio on the platz in Belgium, but damn if the Blonde isn’t identical.”

    chuck

    11 Jun 16 at 10:50

  13. Just curious how Brassneck gets a 2 for food when they have pretty much the identical lineup of items as Strange Fellows or Callister who got 1’s. If it is because of food trucks, I would argue Strange Fellows does just as well on that front.

    Stefan

    11 Jun 16 at 12:06

  14. @Stefan – BN has both lunch and dinner carts (e.g. right now The Local Omnivore is open). P49 has a cart every night.

    Callister and SF have had, in my experience, only sporadic carts available. Usually something is there on Fridays and Saturdays, but not even always then. I’ve been at both during the week only to find out cured meat was the only thing on the menu…

    I’m always looking for new intel, though. If we can reliably establish nightly, reliable carts at either location I’ll adjust accordingly.

    chuck

    11 Jun 16 at 12:40

  15. Thank you, thank you. Life is too short to have to figure out where the bad or boring beer is by trial and error.

    James West

    12 Jun 16 at 23:31

  16. @James – This list is more about the tasting rooms in general, and not just the beer (see Postmark’s fairly high score, for example).

    Luckily the beer score is broken out, so you can resort by that to get a beer-focused list.

    As well, I highly recommend community-sourced review sites like ratebeer.com and beeradvocate.com. Why trust some random dude’s blog on the internet when you can lean on the expertise of thousands of equally massive beer geeks at once?

    chuck

    13 Jun 16 at 08:34

Leave a Reply